Mike Haynes By guest blogger Mike Haynes
Every youth pastor knows the pressure of getting a sermon ready for Wednesday night. The countdown is on, and maybe the outline is set, but something feels off. Perhaps the message isn’t connecting to real-life situations, or you’re worried students will zone out five minutes into the talk.
The truth is, how we prepare our sermons shapes how students receive them. Unfortunately, there’s one significant mistake many youth pastors make—one that can leave students feeling disengaged, confused, or even indifferent to the gospel message.
The #1 Mistake: Prioritizing Delivery Over Discipleship
It’s easy to fall into the trap of believing that a great sermon is all about:
Every youth pastor knows the pressure of getting a sermon ready for Wednesday night. The countdown is on, and maybe the outline is set, but something feels off. Perhaps the message isn’t connecting to real-life situations, or you’re worried students will zone out five minutes into the talk.
The truth is, how we prepare our sermons shapes how students receive them. Unfortunately, there’s one significant mistake many youth pastors make—one that can leave students feeling disengaged, confused, or even indifferent to the gospel message.
The #1 Mistake: Prioritizing Delivery Over Discipleship
It’s easy to fall into the trap of believing that a great sermon is all about:
· Delivering a dynamic and engaging performance
· Sharing funny or relatable stories
· Getting positive feedback from students like, “That was great!”
But here’s the reality: youth ministry isn’t about delivering a polished TED Talk—it’s about forming lifelong disciples of Jesus. Students don’t need the most entertaining sermon; they need a clear, gospel-centered message that fosters real spiritual growth.
The Pitfall of Performance-Based Sermon Prep
When youth pastors focus too much on performance, it often shows up in these ways:
1. Stories Overshadowing Scripture
While stories can make sermons engaging, they should never take precedence over the Bible. If students remember your funny story but not the gospel truth behind it, the message has missed the mark.
Solution: Always let Scripture lead the way. Stories should serve as illustrations to clarify biblical truths, not the main attraction.
2. Chasing “Wow” Moments Instead of Heart Change
Object lessons, viral videos, or shocking statistics might grab attention, but without a clear application, they can become distractions.
Solution: Ensure every illustration leads to a concrete “so what?” moment that helps students apply the lesson to their lives.
3. Focusing on Energy Over Depth
While building energy in the room is good, lasting faith is built on depth. If students are only engaged because of your charisma, their faith may not hold up outside of youth group.
Solution: Equip students to engage with the Bible on their own, beyond just hearing your words.
Shifting to a Discipleship-First Approach
To move from performance-driven preaching to transformative discipleship, try these sermon prep strategies:
1. Define the “Why” Before the “What”
Before you start writing your sermon, ask yourself:
· What key truth do I want students to take away?
· How does this message point to Jesus?
· What real-life application will this offer?
If your message doesn’t lead to transformation, it’s simply information.
2. Make Scripture the Foundation
Instead of crafting a theme and finding a verse to match, start with Scripture. Let the Bible shape your message rather than using it as an afterthought.
· Read the passage multiple times to understand its context.
· Ask what it reveals about God and how it applies to today’s world.
· Focus on biblical depth over superficial inspiration.
3. Keep the Gospel Central
Regardless of the sermon topic—whether it’s relationships, anxiety, or identity—ensure the gospel is always at the heart of your message.
· Don’t assume students already understand the gospel.
· Highlight how Jesus is the ultimate answer to every struggle.
· Offer opportunities for real-life application and growth.
4. Preach for Monday, Not Just Wednesday
A great sermon doesn’t just resonate during youth group—it equips students to carry their faith into the rest of the week.
· Provide practical steps for students to live out biblical truths.
· Prepare them to think biblically when facing real-world challenges.
Transforming Sermon Prep for Real Impact
The goal of a sermon isn’t just to engage students for 20 minutes—it’s to cultivate a faith that endures. When youth pastors shift their focus from performance to discipleship, they help students:
· See Jesus more clearly
· Understand Scripture deeply
· Apply biblical truths to their everyday lives
Avoiding common sermon prep mistakes is crucial, but having the right curriculum as a foundation makes the process even smoother.
· Sharing funny or relatable stories
· Getting positive feedback from students like, “That was great!”
But here’s the reality: youth ministry isn’t about delivering a polished TED Talk—it’s about forming lifelong disciples of Jesus. Students don’t need the most entertaining sermon; they need a clear, gospel-centered message that fosters real spiritual growth.
The Pitfall of Performance-Based Sermon Prep
When youth pastors focus too much on performance, it often shows up in these ways:
1. Stories Overshadowing Scripture
While stories can make sermons engaging, they should never take precedence over the Bible. If students remember your funny story but not the gospel truth behind it, the message has missed the mark.
Solution: Always let Scripture lead the way. Stories should serve as illustrations to clarify biblical truths, not the main attraction.
2. Chasing “Wow” Moments Instead of Heart Change
Object lessons, viral videos, or shocking statistics might grab attention, but without a clear application, they can become distractions.
Solution: Ensure every illustration leads to a concrete “so what?” moment that helps students apply the lesson to their lives.
3. Focusing on Energy Over Depth
While building energy in the room is good, lasting faith is built on depth. If students are only engaged because of your charisma, their faith may not hold up outside of youth group.
Solution: Equip students to engage with the Bible on their own, beyond just hearing your words.
Shifting to a Discipleship-First Approach
To move from performance-driven preaching to transformative discipleship, try these sermon prep strategies:
1. Define the “Why” Before the “What”
Before you start writing your sermon, ask yourself:
· What key truth do I want students to take away?
· How does this message point to Jesus?
· What real-life application will this offer?
If your message doesn’t lead to transformation, it’s simply information.
2. Make Scripture the Foundation
Instead of crafting a theme and finding a verse to match, start with Scripture. Let the Bible shape your message rather than using it as an afterthought.
· Read the passage multiple times to understand its context.
· Ask what it reveals about God and how it applies to today’s world.
· Focus on biblical depth over superficial inspiration.
3. Keep the Gospel Central
Regardless of the sermon topic—whether it’s relationships, anxiety, or identity—ensure the gospel is always at the heart of your message.
· Don’t assume students already understand the gospel.
· Highlight how Jesus is the ultimate answer to every struggle.
· Offer opportunities for real-life application and growth.
4. Preach for Monday, Not Just Wednesday
A great sermon doesn’t just resonate during youth group—it equips students to carry their faith into the rest of the week.
· Provide practical steps for students to live out biblical truths.
· Prepare them to think biblically when facing real-world challenges.
Transforming Sermon Prep for Real Impact
The goal of a sermon isn’t just to engage students for 20 minutes—it’s to cultivate a faith that endures. When youth pastors shift their focus from performance to discipleship, they help students:
· See Jesus more clearly
· Understand Scripture deeply
· Apply biblical truths to their everyday lives
Avoiding common sermon prep mistakes is crucial, but having the right curriculum as a foundation makes the process even smoother.
Mike Haynes is a youth ministry veteran and the creator of G Shades Youth Ministry Curriculum. A vibrant contributor to the youth ministry landscape, Mike’s passion is to help students and youth pastors alike see life through the lens of the gospel. He and his wife Anna have five kids spanning elementary, middle, and high school.
Socials: @mikeehaynes on Instagram
Socials: @mikeehaynes on Instagram
RSS Feed
